Rosenthal, Maurycy performance comparisons

Mazurka, Op. 63, No. 3

full tempo curve  Rosenthal 1930 59.8%   Rosenthal 1931c 14.2%   Rosenthal 1931b   8.4%   Rosenthal 1931   5.6%   Rosenthal 1931d   2.7%   Malcuzynski 1961   1.9%   Average 0.92 Rosenthal 1931b 0.92 Rosenthal 1931c 0.91 Rosenthal 1931d 0.88 Rosenthal 1931 0.70 Rachmaninoff 1923 0.63 Moravec 1969	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1930 62.1%   Rosenthal 1931c   7.4%   Rosenthal 1931   4.7%   Rachmaninoff 1923   4.4%   Rosenthal 1931d   3.2%   Malcuzynski 1961   2.6%   Rosenthal 1931b   1.7%   Moravec 1969   1.1%   Rabcewiczowa 1932   1.1%   Smith 1975   1.1%   Gornostaeva 1994 0.86 Rosenthal 1931c 0.84 Rosenthal 1931b 0.83 Rosenthal 1931d 0.82 Rosenthal 1931	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1930 42.9%   Rosenthal 1931b 20.3%   Rosenthal 1931c 14.7%   Rosenthal 1931d   5.9%   Rosenthal 1931   2.1%   Average   1.3%   Schilhawsky 1960   1.2%   Brailowsky 1960   1.1%   Czerny 1949 0.88 Rosenthal 1931b 0.88 Rosenthal 1931d 0.86 Rosenthal 1931c 0.85 Rosenthal 1931 0.75 Rachmaninoff 1923 0.74 Brailowsky 1960 0.57 Blumental 1952 0.55 Horowitz 1949	global beat dynamics  Rosenthal 1930 62.7%   Rosenthal 1931c   6.4%   Groot 1988   3.8%   Rachmaninoff 1923   3.5%   Rosenthal 1931d   2.5%   Gornostaeva 1994   1.9%   Badura 1965   1.7%   Rosenthal 1931b   1.5%   Afanassiev 2001   1.4%   Ezaki 2006   1.2%   Uninsky 1971   1.0%   Sztompka 1959 0.84 Rosenthal 1931c 0.77 Rosenthal 1931b 0.77 Rosenthal 1931 0.73 Rosenthal 1931d 0.58 Rachmaninoff 1923	smoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1930 51.2%   Rosenthal 1931c 13.7%   Groot 1988   4.8%   Friedman 1930   4.0%   Rosenthal 1931   2.5%   Harasiewicz 1955   2.4%   Gornostaeva 1994   1.9%   Rachmaninoff 1923   1.9%   Czerny 1949   1.3%   Magaloff 1978 0.73 Rosenthal 1931c 0.62 Rosenthal 1931 0.56 Rosenthal 1931b	desmoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1930 28.8%   Rosenthal 1931d 14.6%   Afanassiev 2001   9.4%   Rosenthal 1931b   7.8%   Rubinstein 1939   7.1%   Sztompka 1959   6.1%   Ezaki 2006   6.1%   Rachmaninoff 1923   5.1%   Average   2.9%   Farrell 1958   2.1%   Gierzod 1998   1.6%   Rosenthal 1931 0.83 Rosenthal 1931b 0.82 Rosenthal 1931 0.82 Rosenthal 1931c 0.81 Rosenthal 1931d 0.78 Rachmaninoff 1923 0.75 Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.68 Afanassiev 2001 0.66 Ezaki 2006 0.62 Gornostaeva 1994 0.57 Rosen 1989S 0.56 Czerny 1949 0.55 Sztompka 1959	joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1930 73.2%   Rosenthal 1931c   8.0%   Rosenthal 1931d   4.8%   Rosenthal 1931b   2.8%   Rachmaninoff 1923   2.0%   Rosenthal 1931   1.0%   Moravec 1969 0.93 Rosenthal 1931c 0.92 Rosenthal 1931b 0.91 Rosenthal 1931d 0.90 Rosenthal 1931 0.68 Rachmaninoff 1923	smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1930 69.1%   Rosenthal 1931c   6.7%   Rosenthal 1931   4.9%   Rachmaninoff 1923   3.1%   Gornostaeva 1994   1.9%   Groot 1988   1.8%   Moravec 1969   1.3%   Magaloff 1978   1.2%   Rosenthal 1931d   1.2%   Smith 1975 0.89 Rosenthal 1931c 0.84 Rosenthal 1931 0.83 Rosenthal 1931b 0.81 Rosenthal 1931d	desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1930 34.9%   Rosenthal 1931b 32.5%   Rosenthal 1931d 10.7%   Rosenthal 1931c   6.9%   Average   2.8%   Rachmaninoff 1923   2.5%   Rosenthal 1931   1.1%   Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.91 Rosenthal 1931b 0.90 Rosenthal 1931c 0.89 Rosenthal 1931 0.89 Rosenthal 1931d 0.86 Rachmaninoff 1923 0.73 Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.72 Brailowsky 1960 0.70 Afanassiev 2001 0.55 Horowitz 1949
full tempo curve  Rosenthal 1931 87.6%   Rosenthal 1931b   6.5%   Rosenthal 1931d   2.1%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.96 Rosenthal 1931d 0.96 Rosenthal 1931b 0.94 Rosenthal 1931c 0.88 Rosenthal 1930 0.63 Moravec 1969	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931 90.9%   Rosenthal 1931b   4.5%   Rosenthal 1931d   1.2%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.98 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931d 0.94 Rosenthal 1931c 0.82 Rosenthal 1930 0.57 Moravec 1969	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931 79.0%   Rosenthal 1931b   7.7%   Rosenthal 1931c   6.5%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.94 Rosenthal 1931b 0.94 Rosenthal 1931d 0.90 Rosenthal 1931c 0.85 Rosenthal 1930 0.62 Brailowsky 1960	global beat dynamics  Rosenthal 1931 98.7%   Rosenthal 1931b 0.99 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931d 0.93 Rosenthal 1931c 0.77 Rosenthal 1930	smoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931 95.4%   Rosenthal 1931b   1.3%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.97 Rosenthal 1931b 0.92 Rosenthal 1931d 0.78 Rosenthal 1931c 0.62 Rosenthal 1930	desmoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931 97.7%   Rosenthal 1931b   1.3%   Rosenthal 1931c 1.00 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931d 0.95 Rosenthal 1931c 0.84 Gierzod 1998 0.82 Rosenthal 1930 0.82 Ferenczy 1958 0.72 Ezaki 2006 0.70 Afanassiev 2001 0.64 Cohen 1997 0.63 Anderszewski 2003 0.62 Bacha 2000 0.61 Badura 1965 0.59 Cortot 1951 0.58 Czerny 1949 0.57 Brailowsky 1960	joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931 97.0%   Rosenthal 1931b   1.7%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.99 Rosenthal 1931b 0.98 Rosenthal 1931d 0.96 Rosenthal 1931c 0.90 Rosenthal 1930 0.58 Brailowsky 1960	smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931 95.1%   Rosenthal 1931b   2.9%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.99 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931d 0.93 Rosenthal 1931c 0.84 Rosenthal 1930	desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931 94.9%   Rosenthal 1931b   2.3%   Rosenthal 1931d   1.5%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.99 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931d 0.96 Rosenthal 1931c 0.89 Rosenthal 1930 0.78 Ferenczy 1958 0.70 Brailowsky 1960 0.61 Ezaki 2006 0.60 Gierzod 1998 0.56 Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.56 Afanassiev 2001 0.55 Cohen 1997
full tempo curve  Rosenthal 1931b 67.7%   Rosenthal 1931 19.6%   Rosenthal 1931d   9.3%   Rosenthal 1931c   1.1%   Rosenthal 1930 0.97 Rosenthal 1931d 0.96 Rosenthal 1931 0.95 Rosenthal 1931c 0.92 Rosenthal 1930 0.62 Moravec 1969	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931b 70.3%   Rosenthal 1931 24.8%   Rosenthal 1931d   2.9%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.98 Rosenthal 1931 0.98 Rosenthal 1931d 0.95 Rosenthal 1931c 0.84 Rosenthal 1930 0.57 Moravec 1969	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931b 49.7%   Rosenthal 1931 29.0%   Rosenthal 1931d 15.8%   Rosenthal 1931c   1.8%   Rosenthal 1930 0.95 Rosenthal 1931d 0.94 Rosenthal 1931 0.94 Rosenthal 1931c 0.88 Rosenthal 1930	global beat dynamics  Rosenthal 1931b 90.5%   Rosenthal 1931   8.3%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.99 Rosenthal 1931 0.99 Rosenthal 1931d 0.93 Rosenthal 1931c 0.77 Rosenthal 1930 0.55 Brailowsky 1960	smoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931b 54.7%   Rosenthal 1931 42.9%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.97 Rosenthal 1931 0.96 Rosenthal 1931d 0.79 Rosenthal 1931c 0.56 Rosenthal 1930	desmoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931b 91.0%   Rosenthal 1931   7.9%   Rosenthal 1931d 1.00 Rosenthal 1931 0.99 Rosenthal 1931d 0.95 Rosenthal 1931c 0.83 Rosenthal 1930 0.82 Ferenczy 1958 0.82 Gierzod 1998 0.74 Ezaki 2006 0.72 Afanassiev 2001 0.65 Brailowsky 1960 0.64 Cohen 1997 0.62 Anderszewski 2003 0.58 Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.56 Badura 1965 0.56 Uninsky 1971 0.56 Czerny 1949	joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931b 83.0%   Rosenthal 1931 15.5%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.99 Rosenthal 1931 0.99 Rosenthal 1931d 0.97 Rosenthal 1931c 0.92 Rosenthal 1930 0.59 Brailowsky 1960	smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931b 60.8%   Rosenthal 1931 37.8%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.99 Rosenthal 1931 0.98 Rosenthal 1931d 0.94 Rosenthal 1931c 0.83 Rosenthal 1930	desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931b 77.5%   Rosenthal 1931 17.7%   Rosenthal 1931d   3.8%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.99 Rosenthal 1931 0.99 Rosenthal 1931d 0.97 Rosenthal 1931c 0.91 Rosenthal 1930 0.75 Ferenczy 1958 0.67 Brailowsky 1960 0.58 Cohen 1997 0.58 Afanassiev 2001
full tempo curve  Rosenthal 1931c 53.5%   Rosenthal 1931b 30.3%   Rosenthal 1931d   8.6%   Rosenthal 1931   3.7%   Rosenthal 1930 0.96 Rosenthal 1931d 0.95 Rosenthal 1931b 0.94 Rosenthal 1931 0.92 Rosenthal 1930 0.65 Moravec 1969	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931c 47.4%   Rosenthal 1931b 24.0%   Rosenthal 1931 21.5%   Rosenthal 1931d   2.0%   Rosenthal 1930 0.95 Rosenthal 1931b 0.94 Rosenthal 1931d 0.94 Rosenthal 1931 0.86 Rosenthal 1930	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931c 48.1%   Rosenthal 1931b 34.9%   Rosenthal 1931d   6.5%   Rosenthal 1931   4.4%   Rosenthal 1930 0.94 Rosenthal 1931d 0.94 Rosenthal 1931b 0.90 Rosenthal 1931 0.86 Rosenthal 1930 0.58 Rachmaninoff 1923 0.55 Brailowsky 1960 0.55 Moravec 1969	global beat dynamics  Rosenthal 1931c 47.4%   Rosenthal 1931b 22.4%   Rosenthal 1931 13.5%   Rosenthal 1930   7.0%   Rosenthal 1931d   1.5%   Paderewski 1930 0.93 Rosenthal 1931 0.93 Rosenthal 1931b 0.92 Rosenthal 1931d 0.84 Rosenthal 1930	smoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931c 43.0%   Rosenthal 1930 14.1%   Rosenthal 1931 10.8%   Rosenthal 1931b   6.0%   Smith 1975   4.9%   Paderewski 1930   3.7%   Magaloff 1978   3.5%   Rosenthal 1931d   2.3%   Gierzod 1998 0.79 Rosenthal 1931b 0.78 Rosenthal 1931 0.77 Rosenthal 1931d 0.73 Rosenthal 1930	desmoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931c 67.9%   Rosenthal 1931b 14.6%   Rosenthal 1931   8.3%   Rosenthal 1931d   2.6%   Cohen 1997 0.95 Rosenthal 1931 0.95 Rosenthal 1931b 0.94 Rosenthal 1931d 0.82 Rosenthal 1930 0.71 Ezaki 2006 0.70 Cortot 1951 0.69 Cohen 1997 0.65 Gierzod 1998 0.59 Ferenczy 1958 0.58 Czerny 1949 0.56 Mohovich 1999	joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931c 62.8%   Rosenthal 1931b 14.3%   Rosenthal 1931d 11.4%   Rosenthal 1931   8.2%   Rosenthal 1930 0.97 Rosenthal 1931b 0.96 Rosenthal 1931 0.96 Rosenthal 1931d 0.93 Rosenthal 1930 0.58 Magaloff 1978	smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931c 54.6%   Rosenthal 1931 20.1%   Rosenthal 1930 11.1%   Rosenthal 1931d   7.1%   Rosenthal 1931b   1.1%   Ohlsson 1999   1.0%   Blumental 1952 0.94 Rosenthal 1931b 0.93 Rosenthal 1931d 0.93 Rosenthal 1931 0.89 Rosenthal 1930	desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931c 65.6%   Rosenthal 1931b 18.3%   Rosenthal 1931 11.7%   Rosenthal 1931d 0.97 Rosenthal 1931b 0.96 Rosenthal 1931 0.96 Rosenthal 1931d 0.90 Rosenthal 1930 0.62 Ezaki 2006 0.61 Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.56 Ferenczy 1958
full tempo curve  Rosenthal 1931d 73.3%   Rosenthal 1931b 14.0%   Rosenthal 1931c   9.7%   Rosenthal 1931   1.5%   Rosenthal 1930 0.97 Rosenthal 1931b 0.96 Rosenthal 1931 0.96 Rosenthal 1931c 0.91 Rosenthal 1930 0.62 Moravec 1969	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931d 85.1%   Rosenthal 1931b   7.6%   Rosenthal 1931   5.0%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.98 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931 0.94 Rosenthal 1931c 0.83 Rosenthal 1930 0.57 Moravec 1969	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931d 66.8%   Rosenthal 1931b 21.1%   Rosenthal 1931c   6.8%   Rosenthal 1931   2.9%   Rosenthal 1930 0.95 Rosenthal 1931b 0.94 Rosenthal 1931c 0.94 Rosenthal 1931 0.88 Rosenthal 1930 0.62 Brailowsky 1960 0.57 Rachmaninoff 1923	global beat dynamics  Rosenthal 1931d 97.0%   Rosenthal 1931b 0.99 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931 0.92 Rosenthal 1931c 0.73 Rosenthal 1930	smoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931d 90.6%   Rosenthal 1931b   4.2%   Rosenthal 1931 0.96 Rosenthal 1931b 0.92 Rosenthal 1931 0.77 Rosenthal 1931c 0.55 Magaloff 1978	desmoothed dynamics (0.5)  Rosenthal 1931d 94.3%   Rosenthal 1931b   2.2%   Rosenthal 1931   1.3%   Gornostaeva 1994 0.99 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931 0.94 Rosenthal 1931c 0.81 Rosenthal 1930 0.71 Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.68 Ezaki 2006 0.65 Ferenczy 1958 0.62 Afanassiev 2001 0.57 Cohen 1997 0.55 Czerny 1949	joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931d 94.1%   Rosenthal 1931b   3.1%   Rosenthal 1931   1.7%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.99 Rosenthal 1931b 0.98 Rosenthal 1931 0.96 Rosenthal 1931c 0.91 Rosenthal 1930 0.62 Brailowsky 1960	smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931d 90.5%   Rosenthal 1931b   6.4%   Rosenthal 1931   1.5%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.98 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931 0.93 Rosenthal 1931c 0.81 Rosenthal 1930	desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Rosenthal 1931d 88.6%   Rosenthal 1931b   7.7%   Rosenthal 1931   2.1%   Rosenthal 1931c 0.99 Rosenthal 1931b 0.97 Rosenthal 1931 0.96 Rosenthal 1931c 0.89 Rosenthal 1930 0.70 Ferenczy 1958 0.66 Brailowsky 1960 0.65 Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.59 Afanassiev 2001 0.55 Rachmaninoff 1923