Milkina, Nina performance comparisons

Mazurka, Op. 17, No. 4

full tempo curve  Milkina 1970 79.0%   Average   3.0%   Perahia 1994   2.7%   Perlemuter 1986   2.4%   Rubinstein 1966   2.1%   Ashkenazy 1981   1.3%   Mohovich 1999 0.77 Rubinstein 1966 0.74 Perlemuter 1986 0.70 Indjic 2001 0.68 Hatto 1997 0.67 Rubinstein 1939 0.64 Lushtak 2004 0.64 Perahia 1994 0.63 Mohovich 1999 0.59 Kushner 1990 0.58 Afanassiev 2001 0.55 Average

smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 37.9%   Average 17.1%   Smith 1975   6.8%   Perlemuter 1986   4.4%   Kushner 1990   4.1%   Rubinstein 1952   3.0%   Osinska 1989   2.6%   Perahia 1994   2.6%   Mohovich 1999   2.1%   Blet 2003   2.1%   Clidat 1994   2.0%   Rubinstein 1966   1.5%   Horowitz 1971 0.64 Rubinstein 1966 0.56 Smith 1975

desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 74.9%   Average   3.5%   Ashkenazy 1981   3.3%   Indjic 2001   3.2%   Perahia 1994   2.6%   Coop 1987   1.7%   Perlemuter 1986   1.6%   Mohovich 1999   1.4%   Rubinstein 1966 0.75 Hatto 1997 0.73 Indjic 2001 0.73 Rubinstein 1939 0.72 Average 0.71 Perlemuter 1986 0.70 Rubinstein 1966 0.69 Coop 1987 0.69 Ashkenazy 1981 0.68 Perahia 1994 0.63 Kushner 1990 0.60 Ohlsson 1999 0.60 Lushtak 2004 0.59 Rubinstein 1952 0.59 Mohovich 1999 0.56 BenOr 1989 0.56 Kissin 1993 0.55 Afanassiev 2001

global beat dynamics  Milkina 1970 41.9%   Rubinstein 1966 30.6%   Average   4.5%   Rubinstein 1952   4.0%   Biret 1990   2.2%   Francois 1956   2.1%   Rosen 1989   1.8%   Mohovich 1999   1.4%   Falvay 1989   1.3%   Perahia 1994 0.78 Rubinstein 1966 0.59 Mohovich 1999

joint tempo / global dynamics  Milkina 1970 77.9%   Average 10.6%   Rubinstein 1966   2.0%   Mohovich 1999   1.3%   Perahia 1994   1.2%   Ashkenazy 1981 0.87 Rubinstein 1966 0.71 Mohovich 1999 0.71 Indjic 2001 0.66 Perlemuter 1986 0.62 Hatto 1997 0.62 Rubinstein 1952 0.58 Smith 1975 0.56 Clidat 1994 0.55 Rubinstein 1939

Mazurka, Op. 24, No. 2

full tempo curve  Milkina 1970 74.2%   Average   3.1%   Rubinstein 1966   2.7%   Fou 1978   1.7%   Falvay 1989   1.4%   Tsujii 2005   1.4%   Rosen 1989   1.1%   Nezu 2005 0.77 Average 0.72 Rubinstein 1966 0.71 Ohlsson 1999 0.70 Rubinstein 1939 0.70 Rubinstein 1952 0.68 Katin 1996 0.66 Nezu 2005 0.64 Tanyel 1992 0.63 Indjic 2001 0.62 Hatto 1997 0.62 Ax 1995 0.62 Tsujii 2005 0.61 Uninsky 1959 0.61 Vardi 1988 0.61 Poblocka 1999 0.60 Fiorentino 1962 0.60 Hatto 1993 0.60 Mohovich 1999 0.56 Clidat 1994 0.55 Ashkenazy 1981 0.55 Osinska 1989 0.55 Kushner 1990 0.55 Fou 1978

smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 29.0%   Rubinstein 1939 12.4%   Fiorentino 1962   9.5%   Katin 1996   7.3%   Average   5.5%   Fou 1978   4.6%   Rubinstein 1966   3.9%   Ohlsson 1999   3.5%   Mohovich 1999   3.4%   Rubinstein 1952   3.4%   Ashkenazy 1981   2.8%   Rosen 1989   2.6%   Kushner 1990   1.7%   Chiu 1999   1.1%   Hatto 1997   1.1%   Osinska 1989 0.71 Rubinstein 1939 0.70 Katin 1996 0.69 Rubinstein 1966 0.68 Fiorentino 1962 0.66 Mohovich 1999 0.65 Rubinstein 1952 0.62 Average 0.58 Clidat 1994 0.58 Ohlsson 1999 0.56 Chiu 1999 0.55 Ax 1995

desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 77.4%   Average   1.7%   Nezu 2005   1.7%   Tsujii 2005   1.6%   Falvay 1989   1.5%   Rubinstein 1966   1.5%   Osinska 1989   1.4%   Zimerman 1975   1.2%   Ezaki 2006   1.0%   Katin 1996 0.74 Average 0.71 Tanyel 1992 0.70 Nezu 2005 0.69 Zimerman 1975 0.68 Kushner 1990 0.62 Indjic 2001 0.61 Ohlsson 1999 0.60 Falvay 1989 0.60 Hatto 1997 0.60 Vardi 1988 0.59 Rubinstein 1966 0.58 Uninsky 1959 0.57 Brailowsky 1960 0.56 Poblocka 1999 0.56 Rubinstein 1952 0.55 Tsujii 2005

global beat dynamics  Milkina 1970 59.2%   Average   8.8%   Falvay 1989   4.3%   Rubinstein 1966   2.8%   Osinska 1989   2.4%   Fiorentino 1962   2.4%   Francois 1956   2.1%   Kushner 1990   1.5%   Rubinstein 1952   1.5%   Poblocka 1999   1.2%   Czerny 1989   1.2%   Nezu 2005   1.0%   Sztompka 1959 0.55 Kushner 1990

smoothed beat dynamics  Milkina 1970 29.5%   Average 17.3%   Kushner 1990   8.1%   Falvay 1989   6.3%   Magaloff 1977   6.2%   Uninsky 1959   3.8%   Nezu 2005   3.0%   Rubinstein 1939   2.5%   Ezaki 2006   2.2%   Shebanova 2002   2.0%   Fiorentino 1962   1.6%   Meguri 1997   1.4%   Poblocka 1999   1.4%   Czerny 1989   1.2%   Osinska 1989   1.0%   Luisada 2008

desmoothed beat dynamics  Milkina 1970 38.9%   Average 34.1%   Rubinstein 1966   7.7%   Clidat 1994   3.5%   Falvay 1989   2.2%   Francois 1956   2.2%   Ohlsson 1999   1.5%   Kiepura 1999   1.2%   Malcuzynski 1961   1.0%   Fiorentino 1962 0.73 Rubinstein 1966 0.67 Chiu 1999 0.65 Mohovich 1999 0.64 Clidat 1994 0.64 Poblocka 1999 0.64 Falvay 1989 0.60 Shebanova 2002 0.59 Ezaki 2006 0.59 Csalog 1996 0.56 Sztompka 1959

joint tempo / global dynamics  Milkina 1970 81.8%   Average   5.2%   Rubinstein 1966   1.3%   Nezu 2005   1.2%   Falvay 1989   1.1%   Rubinstein 1952 0.79 Rubinstein 1966 0.74 Average 0.70 Uninsky 1959 0.69 Poblocka 1999 0.68 Rubinstein 1952 0.68 Ohlsson 1999 0.63 Rubinstein 1939 0.62 Kushner 1990 0.60 Katin 1996 0.57 Ax 1995 0.55 Biret 1990 0.55 Mohovich 1999

smoothed joint features  Milkina 1970 48.9%   Average   8.0%   Rubinstein 1966   7.0%   Ashkenazy 1981   6.7%   Fiorentino 1962   5.2%   Rubinstein 1939   4.2%   Fou 1978   3.4%   Osinska 1989   2.5%   Rubinstein 1952   2.4%   Nezu 2005   1.3%   Chiu 1999 0.72 Rubinstein 1966 0.70 Rubinstein 1952 0.64 Rubinstein 1939 0.63 Katin 1996 0.61 Magaloff 1977 0.59 Uninsky 1959 0.59 Average 0.58 Ashkenazy 1981 0.57 Fiorentino 1962 0.55 Fou 1978

desmoothed joint features  Milkina 1970 85.7%   Average   4.5%   Rubinstein 1966 0.78 Average 0.77 Falvay 1989 0.76 Rubinstein 1966 0.75 Poblocka 1999 0.70 Ohlsson 1999 0.66 Biret 1990 0.66 Nezu 2005 0.66 Kushner 1990 0.64 Rubinstein 1952 0.63 Osinska 1989 0.62 Mohovich 1999 0.61 Tsujii 2005 0.57 Uninsky 1959 0.56 Katin 1996

Mazurka, Op. 30, No. 2

full tempo curve  Milkina 1970 84.4%   Average   3.3%   Rubinstein 1952   2.5%   Rubinstein 1939   2.3%   Mohovich 1999   1.5%   Hatto 1997   1.1%   Rubinstein 1966 0.89 Average 0.85 Rubinstein 1939 0.82 Rubinstein 1952 0.78 Rubinstein 1966 0.78 Clidat 1994 0.76 Mohovich 1999 0.70 Biret 1990 0.65 Luisada 1990 0.61 Olejniczac 1990 0.59 Poblocka 1999 0.56 Fliere 1977 0.55 Hatto 1997

smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 80.9%   Average   3.2%   Rubinstein 1952   1.4%   Lushtak 2004   1.3%   Rangell 2001   1.3%   Cortot 1951   1.2%   Rubinstein 1966   1.1%   Tsong 1993 0.86 Average 0.65 Biret 1990 0.64 Rubinstein 1966 0.62 Rubinstein 1952 0.62 Mohovich 1999 0.60 Clidat 1994 0.57 Rubinstein 1939 0.57 Shebanova 2002

desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 73.8%   Average   9.4%   Rubinstein 1939   6.2%   Mohovich 1999   2.6%   Rubinstein 1952   1.5%   Hatto 1997   1.5%   Ferenczy 1956 0.89 Rubinstein 1939 0.85 Average 0.82 Rubinstein 1952 0.78 Rubinstein 1966 0.74 Clidat 1994 0.74 Mohovich 1999 0.67 Luisada 1990 0.65 Hatto 1997 0.62 Fliere 1977 0.62 Biret 1990 0.61 Indjic 2001 0.55 Olejniczac 1990

global beat dynamics  Milkina 1970 72.4%   Average   4.8%   Mohovich 1999   4.0%   Biret 1990   2.7%   Olejniczac 1990   2.6%   Tsong 2005   2.5%   Yaroshinsky 2005   2.2%   Cortot 1951   1.2%   Rubinstein 1952   1.1%   Poblocka 1999 0.78 Average 0.71 Mohovich 1999 0.70 Tsong 2005 0.67 Olejniczac 1990 0.66 Magaloff 1977 0.64 Chiu 1999 0.62 Clidat 1994 0.61 Biret 1990 0.61 Poblocka 1999 0.56 Tsong 1993 0.55 Uninsky 1971

joint tempo / global dynamics  Milkina 1970 91.1%   Average   1.6%   Rubinstein 1952   1.2%   Mohovich 1999   1.1%   Clidat 1994 0.90 Average 0.89 Mohovich 1999 0.82 Clidat 1994 0.78 Rubinstein 1952 0.75 Magaloff 1977 0.74 Biret 1990 0.73 Olejniczac 1990 0.72 Poblocka 1999 0.72 Rubinstein 1939 0.72 Tsong 2005 0.62 Uninsky 1971 0.61 Tsong 1993 0.59 Rubinstein 1966 0.59 Chiu 1999 0.57 Lushtak 2004

Mazurka, Op. 63, No. 3

full tempo curve  Milkina 1970 72.5%   Average   5.4%   Anderszewski 2003   2.6%   Barbosa 1983   2.0%   Czerny 1949   2.0%   Rubinstein 1966   1.8%   Fou 1978 0.77 Average 0.75 Osinska 1989 0.72 Mohovich 1999 0.70 Ezaki 2006 0.70 Biret 1990 0.69 Harasiewicz 1955 0.69 Czerny 1990 0.66 Gierzod 1998 0.65 Kushner 1989 0.63 Anderszewski 2003 0.63 Rosen 1989 0.61 Fou 1978 0.61 Morozova 2008 0.60 Luisada 1991 0.60 Rubinstein 1952 0.59 Kissin 1993 0.59 Rubinstein 1966 0.58 Rubinstein 1939

smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 24.4%   Mohovich 1999 19.1%   Average   8.3%   Osinska 1989   5.0%   Fou 1978   4.4%   Blumental 1952   4.3%   Rosen 1989   4.3%   Kissin 1993   2.5%   Barbosa 1983   2.2%   Rosenthal 1931c   2.2%   Biret 1990   1.9%   Morozova 2008   1.4%   Bacha 2000   1.2%   Afanassiev 2001   1.2%   Csalog 1996   1.1%   Poblocka 1999   1.0%   Harasiewicz 1955   1.0%   Uninsky 1971 0.68 Mohovich 1999 0.65 Biret 1990 0.64 Rosen 1989 0.62 Osinska 1989 0.57 Ezaki 2006

desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 77.6%   Average   3.3%   Gierzod 1998   2.1%   Czerny 1949   2.0%   Kushner 1989   1.3%   Fou 1978   1.1%   Biret 1990   1.0%   Osinska 1989 0.86 Average 0.72 Morozova 2008 0.70 Kushner 1989 0.70 Osinska 1989 0.68 Czerny 1990 0.68 Czerny 1949 0.67 Mohovich 1999 0.66 Rubinstein 1966 0.65 Rubinstein 1952 0.64 Biret 1990 0.63 Barbosa 1983 0.62 Anderszewski 2003 0.62 Boshniakovich 1969 0.61 Gierzod 1998 0.60 Harasiewicz 1955 0.59 Uninsky 1971 0.58 Ezaki 2006 0.57 Malcuzynski 1961 0.56 Fliere 1977 0.55 Gornostaeva 1994 0.55 Indjic 1988

global beat dynamics  Milkina 1970 41.7%   Falvay 1989   8.7%   Rubinstein 1939   7.0%   Tomsic 1995   5.4%   Average   4.4%   Rubinstein 1952   4.1%   Moravec 1969   3.0%   Francois 1956   2.8%   Cohen 1997   2.7%   Luisada 1991   2.2%   Czerny 1949   2.1%   Hatto 1997   1.9%   Osinska 1989   1.8%   Neighaus 1950   1.7%   Harasiewicz 1955 0.73 Falvay 1989 0.62 Rubinstein 1952 0.61 Rubinstein 1966

smoothed dynamics (0.5)  Milkina 1970 15.2%   Fou 1978 13.3%   Kissin 1993 11.3%   Luisada 1991 10.2%   Falvay 1989   8.0%   Rubinstein 1952   6.2%   Average   5.8%   Tomsic 1995   3.4%   Rubinstein 1939   2.6%   Shebanova 2002   2.3%   Moravec 1969   2.1%   Czerny 1949   1.9%   Francois 1956   1.8%   Rangell 2001   1.7%   Cohen 1997   1.1%   Harasiewicz 1955 0.66 Falvay 1989 0.61 Rubinstein 1952 0.60 Kissin 1993 0.58 Shebanova 2002 0.57 Fou 1978

desmoothed dynamics (0.5)  Milkina 1970 26.3%   Falvay 1989 25.3%   Rubinstein 1939   8.2%   Czerny 1949   7.8%   Harasiewicz 1955   7.4%   Hatto 1997   3.9%   Pierdomenico 2008   3.5%   Osinska 1989   3.2%   Rubinstein 1966   2.0%   Neighaus 1950   1.5%   Hatto 1993   1.3%   Uninsky 1971   1.1%   Indjic 1988 0.78 Czerny 1949 0.77 Rubinstein 1939 0.71 Falvay 1989 0.69 Francois 1956 0.67 Moravec 1969 0.67 Biret 1990 0.67 Ferenczy 1958 0.62 Rabcewiczowa 1932 0.62 Rubinstein 1966 0.60 Afanassiev 2001 0.58 Hatto 1997 0.57 Harasiewicz 1955

joint tempo / global dynamics  Milkina 1970 66.2%   Average   8.5%   Fou 1978   6.6%   Rubinstein 1939   2.8%   Czerny 1949   2.6%   Rubinstein 1952   1.3%   Rubinstein 1966   1.1%   Osinska 1989   1.0%   Harasiewicz 1955   1.0%   Ezaki 2006 0.72 Rubinstein 1966 0.67 Rubinstein 1952 0.66 Osinska 1989 0.65 Fou 1978 0.64 Kissin 1993 0.63 Biret 1990 0.62 Average 0.61 Rubinstein 1939 0.60 Harasiewicz 1955 0.60 Falvay 1989 0.56 Luisada 1991 0.55 Mohovich 1999

smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Milkina 1970 25.7%   Fou 1978 21.3%   Average 13.1%   Kissin 1993   8.9%   Luisada 1991   3.0%   Rangell 2001   2.4%   Gierzod 1998   1.9%   Blumental 1952   1.6%   Rubinstein 1939   1.5%   Harasiewicz 1955   1.4%   Rachmaninoff 1923   1.3%   Bacha 2000   1.3%   Mohovich 1999   1.3%   Biret 1990   1.2%   Czerny 1990   1.1%   Kapell 1951   1.0%   Zak 1937 0.71 Kissin 1993 0.64 Fou 1978 0.62 Osinska 1989 0.59 Rubinstein 1952 0.56 Shebanova 2002

desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Milkina 1970 52.6%   Average 21.5%   Czerny 1949   4.5%   Falvay 1989   4.2%   Hatto 1997   3.5%   Rubinstein 1939   2.8%   Rubinstein 1966   2.1%   Osinska 1989   1.4%   Schilhawsky 1960 0.79 Rubinstein 1939 0.78 Czerny 1949 0.75 Biret 1990 0.75 Rubinstein 1966 0.73 Harasiewicz 1955 0.68 Hatto 1997 0.68 Anderszewski 2003 0.67 Francois 1956 0.67 Rubinstein 1952 0.66 Moravec 1969 0.66 Osinska 1989 0.66 Falvay 1989 0.62 Mohovich 1999 0.62 Indjic 1988 0.60 Average 0.60 Hatto 1993 0.59 Gornostaeva 1994 0.57 Afanassiev 2001 0.57 Morozova 2008 0.55 Sokolov 2002 0.55 Barbosa 1983

Mazurka, Op. 68, No. 3

full tempo curve  Milkina 1970 49.7%   Ohlsson 1999 27.8%   Average Tempo   6.7%   Wasowski 1980   2.8%   Ferenczy 1958   2.5%   Osinska 1989   1.9%   Rangell 2001   1.7%   Block 1995   1.4%   Uninsky 1971 0.81 Osinska 1989 0.81 Ohlsson 1999 0.65 Ferenczy 1958 0.60 Rangell 2001

smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 32.5%   Ohlsson 1999 15.0%   Fliere 1977 10.8%   Osinska 1989 10.5%   Average Tempo   4.4%   Ferenczy 1958   4.0%   Wasowski 1980   3.8%   Tomsic 1995   2.9%   Sztompka 1959   1.9%   Lushtak 2004   1.9%   Csalog 1996   1.3%   Uninsky 1971   1.2%   Block 1995   1.1%   Rangell 2001   1.1%   Magaloff 1978   1.0%   Grinberg 1951 0.69 Osinska 1989 0.67 Ohlsson 1999 0.65 Fliere 1977

desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Milkina 1970 79.1%   Average Tempo   5.9%   Wasowski 1980   4.5%   Ohlsson 1999   1.7%   Rangell 2001   1.6%   Ezaki 2006   1.4%   Block 1995   1.2%   Uninsky 1971 0.88 Average Tempo 0.82 Ohlsson 1999 0.79 Osinska 1989 0.76 Rubinstein 1966 0.74 Wasowski 1980 0.74 Kushner 1989 0.73 Ferenczy 1958 0.71 Chiu 1999 0.69 Ezaki 2006 0.65 Rubinstein 1961 0.65 Rangell 2001 0.63 Block 1995 0.63 Lushtak 2004 0.59 Uninsky 1971 0.58 Tomsic 1995

global beat dynamics  Milkina 1970 55.8%   Average Tempo 18.0%   Chiu 1999   3.9%   Ferenczy 1958   2.4%   Richter 1976   2.2%   Kapell 1951   2.2%   Mohovich 1999   2.1%   Rubinstein 1961   1.6%   Uninsky 1971   1.1%   Olejniczak 1990   1.1%   Magaloff 1978   1.0%   Kiepura 1999 0.69 Ferenczy 1958 0.68 Average Tempo 0.63 Chiu 1999 0.62 Mohovich 1999 0.57 Richter 1976

joint tempo / global dynamics  Milkina 1970 71.8%   Average   9.3%   Ferenczy 1958   3.0%   Rubinstein 1966   2.5%   Fliere 1977   1.8%   Ohlsson 1999   1.2%   Osinska 1989   1.2%   Chiu 1999   1.1%   Rubinstein 1961 0.81 Ferenczy 1958 0.71 Ohlsson 1999 0.66 Fliere 1977 0.65 Chiu 1999 0.62 Mohovich 1999 0.60 Average Tempo 0.59 Richter 1976 0.59 Uninsky 1971 0.59 Magaloff 1978 0.59 Osinska 1989 0.56 Cohen 1997 0.56 Rangell 2001 0.55 Lushtak 2004