Hatto, Joyce performance comparisons

Mazurka, Op. 17, No. 4

full tempo curve  Hatto 1997 99.8%   Indjic 2001 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.68 Milkina 1970

smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 99.9%   Indjic 2001 1.00 Indjic 2001

desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 99.8%   Indjic 2001 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.75 Milkina 1970 0.66 Rangell 2001 0.66 Ashkenazy 1981 0.63 Lushtak 2004 0.61 Kissin 1993 0.60 Perlemuter 1986 0.58 Rubinstein 1939 0.58 Mohovich 1999 0.56 Perahia 1994 0.55 Uninsky 1971 0.55 Cohen 1997

global beat dynamics  Hatto 1997 98.7%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.56 Levy 1951 0.56 Falvay 1989

joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1997 99.7%   Indjic 2001 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.62 Milkina 1970 0.59 Ashkenazy 1981

Mazurka, Op. 24, No. 2

full tempo curve  Hatto 1993 57.9%   Indjic 2001 41.2%   Hatto 1997 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.86 Average 0.71 Osinska 1989 0.70 Nezu 2005 0.68 Lushtak 2004 0.67 Malcuzynski 1961 0.67 Tsujii 2005 0.67 Malcuzynski 1951 0.65 Poblocka 1999 0.65 Falvay 1989 0.62 Rangell 2001 0.62 Ohlsson 1999 0.60 Milkina 1970 0.60 Olejniczak 1990 0.59 Shebanova 2002 0.57 Uninsky 1959	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1993 63.9%   Indjic 2001 35.6%   Hatto 1997 1.00 Hatto 1997 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.74 Average 0.63 Magin 1975 0.63 Rangell 2001 0.61 Poblocka 1999 0.57 Osinska 1989 0.57 Malcuzynski 1961 0.57 Malcuzynski 1951 0.56 Biret 1990	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1993 55.4%   Indjic 2001 43.5%   Hatto 1997 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.77 Average 0.69 Nezu 2005 0.68 Tsujii 2005 0.68 Lushtak 2004 0.67 Ohlsson 1999 0.67 Osinska 1989 0.66 Luisada 2008 0.66 Malcuzynski 1951 0.65 Malcuzynski 1961 0.65 Fiorentino 1962 0.59 Katin 1996 0.58 Luisada 1990	global beat dynamics  Hatto 1993 95.5%   Indjic 2001   3.8%   Hatto 1997 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.71 Average 0.64 Magin 1975 0.63 Falvay 1989 0.62 Zimerman 1975 0.58 Shebanova 2002 0.57 Fliere 1977 0.56 Fou 1978 0.55 Luisada 1990 0.55 Barbosa 1983	smoothed beat dynamics  Hatto 1993 59.4%   Hatto 1997 39.2%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.98 Hatto 1997 0.55 Sztompka 1959	desmoothed beat dynamics  Hatto 1993 95.5%   Indjic 2001   3.6%   Hatto 1997 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.69 Average 0.68 Luisada 1990 0.68 Fliere 1977 0.62 Poblocka 1999 0.61 Zimerman 1975 0.60 Fou 1978 0.56 Rubinstein 1939 0.56 Ashkenazy 1981 0.55 Bacha 1998	joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1993 89.5%   Indjic 2001 10.2%   Hatto 1997 1.00 Hatto 1997 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.87 Average 0.73 Malcuzynski 1961 0.72 Falvay 1989 0.72 Poblocka 1999 0.69 Magin 1975 0.66 Ohlsson 1999 0.63 Uninsky 1959 0.63 Nezu 2005 0.62 Osinska 1989 0.61 Shebanova 2002 0.59 Zimerman 1975 0.58 Katin 1996 0.58 Fou 1978 0.55 Lushtak 2004 0.55 Tsujii 2005	smoothed joint features  Hatto 1993 76.5%   Indjic 2001 23.2%   Hatto 1997 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.77 Average 0.75 Magin 1975 0.66 Falvay 1989 0.63 Malcuzynski 1961 0.61 Poblocka 1999 0.60 Uninsky 1959 0.56 Shebanova 2002	desmoothed joint features  Hatto 1993 92.7%   Indjic 2001   6.8%   Hatto 1997 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.86 Average 0.78 Luisada 1990 0.71 Tsujii 2005 0.71 Malcuzynski 1961 0.69 Falvay 1989 0.67 Lushtak 2004 0.66 Fiorentino 1962 0.66 Fou 1978 0.65 Poblocka 1999 0.65 Rubinstein 1939 0.62 Vardi 1988 0.62 Nezu 2005 0.61 Fliere 1977 0.60 Zimerman 1975 0.57 Olejniczak 1990 0.57 Luisada 2008 0.55 BenOr 1989
full tempo curve  Hatto 1997 90.5%   Indjic 2001   8.9%   Hatto 1993 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.86 Average 0.72 Nezu 2005 0.71 Osinska 1989 0.69 Lushtak 2004 0.67 Tsujii 2005 0.66 Rangell 2001 0.66 Poblocka 1999 0.64 Malcuzynski 1961 0.63 Falvay 1989 0.63 Malcuzynski 1951 0.62 Milkina 1970 0.62 Ohlsson 1999 0.61 Shebanova 2002 0.59 Uninsky 1959 0.59 Olejniczak 1990 0.58 Magin 1975	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 92.0%   Indjic 2001   7.6%   Hatto 1993 1.00 Hatto 1993 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.73 Average 0.65 Magin 1975 0.64 Rangell 2001 0.60 Poblocka 1999 0.59 Biret 1990 0.57 Malcuzynski 1951 0.57 Malcuzynski 1961 0.55 Osinska 1989	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 89.8%   Indjic 2001   9.4%   Hatto 1993 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.77 Average 0.73 Lushtak 2004 0.73 Nezu 2005 0.72 Ohlsson 1999 0.70 Tsujii 2005 0.70 Osinska 1989 0.65 Luisada 2008 0.63 Katin 1996 0.60 Fiorentino 1962 0.60 Milkina 1970 0.59 Vardi 1988 0.57 Malcuzynski 1951 0.57 Malcuzynski 1961 0.56 Kushner 1990	global beat dynamics  Hatto 1997 90.1%   Indjic 2001   8.8%   Hatto 1993 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.73 Average 0.66 Falvay 1989 0.59 Shebanova 2002 0.59 Uninsky 1959 0.58 Magin 1975 0.56 Ohlsson 1999 0.56 Fliere 1977 0.56 Sztompka 1959 0.55 Poblocka 1999	smoothed beat dynamics  Hatto 1997 84.2%   Indjic 2001 13.6%   Hatto 1993 0.98 Hatto 1993 0.98 Indjic 2001 0.57 Shebanova 2002 0.56 Ohlsson 1999 0.56 Falvay 1989 0.55 Sztompka 1959	desmoothed beat dynamics  Hatto 1997 91.8%   Indjic 2001   7.1%   Hatto 1993 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.67 Luisada 1990 0.66 Fliere 1977 0.65 Average 0.64 Poblocka 1999 0.61 Csalog 1996 0.58 Ashkenazy 1981 0.58 Rubinstein 1939 0.56 Horszowski 1983	joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1997 92.8%   Indjic 2001   6.9%   Hatto 1993 1.00 Hatto 1993 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.88 Average 0.74 Falvay 1989 0.73 Malcuzynski 1961 0.72 Poblocka 1999 0.71 Ohlsson 1999 0.71 Magin 1975 0.69 Uninsky 1959 0.66 Nezu 2005 0.64 Shebanova 2002 0.63 Osinska 1989 0.58 Katin 1996 0.58 Tsujii 2005 0.57 Fou 1978 0.56 Zimerman 1975	smoothed joint features  Hatto 1997 92.1%   Indjic 2001   7.5%   Hatto 1993 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.76 Magin 1975 0.75 Average 0.67 Falvay 1989 0.64 Malcuzynski 1961 0.62 Uninsky 1959 0.60 Poblocka 1999 0.59 Shebanova 2002	desmoothed joint features  Hatto 1997 94.0%   Indjic 2001   5.6%   Hatto 1993 1.00 Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.85 Average 0.71 Tsujii 2005 0.70 Nezu 2005 0.70 Falvay 1989 0.69 Lushtak 2004 0.68 Luisada 1990 0.66 Poblocka 1999 0.64 Malcuzynski 1961 0.64 Rubinstein 1939 0.62 Fou 1978 0.62 Osinska 1989 0.61 Vardi 1988 0.58 BenOr 1989 0.58 Malcuzynski 1951 0.58 Fliere 1977 0.56 Luisada 2008

Mazurka, Op. 30, No. 2

full tempo curve  Hatto 1997 98.6%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.76 Average 0.64 Luisada 1990 0.64 Rubinstein 1952 0.60 Poblocka 1999 0.59 Rubinstein 1939 0.55 Milkina 1970

smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 99.1%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Indjic 2001

desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 98.1%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.87 Average 0.75 Rubinstein 1952 0.74 Poblocka 1999 0.71 Rubinstein 1939 0.69 Biret 1990 0.67 Luisada 1990 0.65 Milkina 1970 0.64 Francois 1956 0.55 Fliere 1977 0.55 Olejniczac 1990 0.55 Rubinstein 1966

global beat dynamics  Hatto 1997 97.8%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Indjic 2001

joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1997 99.3%   Indjic 2001 1.00 Indjic 2001

Mazurka, Op. 63, No. 3

full tempo curve  Hatto 1993 77.9%   Indjic 1988 21.6%   Hatto 1997 1.00 Indjic 1988 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.67 Average 0.61 Gierzod 1998 0.60 Friedman 1923b 0.59 Osinska 1989 0.58 Friedman 1923 0.57 Uninsky 1971 0.56 Fliere 1977 0.56 Czerny 1949 0.55 Harasiewicz 1955	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1993 67.9%   Indjic 1988 31.8%   Hatto 1997 1.00 Hatto 1997 1.00 Indjic 1988 0.67 Friedman 1923b 0.66 Friedman 1923 0.61 Friedman 1930 0.56 Neighaus 1950	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1993 77.5%   Indjic 1988 21.8%   Hatto 1997 0.99 Indjic 1988 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.77 Average 0.70 Osinska 1989 0.70 Harasiewicz 1955 0.67 Czerny 1990 0.67 Gierzod 1998 0.66 Rubinstein 1966 0.66 Blumental 1952 0.60 Czerny 1949 0.60 Magaloff 1978 0.59 Uninsky 1971 0.56 Shebanova 2002	global beat dynamics  Hatto 1993 99.0%   Indjic 1988 0.99 Indjic 1988 0.94 Hatto 1997 0.74 Ashkenazy 1981 0.65 Luisada 1991 0.56 Magin 1975	smoothed dynamics (0.5)  Hatto 1993 98.5%   Indjic 1988 0.99 Indjic 1988 0.90 Hatto 1997 0.61 Ashkenazy 1981 0.55 Anderszewski 2003	desmoothed dynamics (0.5)  Hatto 1993 98.5%   Indjic 1988 0.99 Indjic 1988 0.94 Hatto 1997 0.87 Ashkenazy 1981 0.82 Magin 1975 0.78 Shebanova 2002 0.75 Luisada 1991 0.74 Richter 1976 0.73 Kapell 1951 0.71 Groot 1988 0.68 Czerny 1990 0.67 Garcia 2007b 0.67 Kissin 1993 0.62 Chiu 1999 0.62 Barbosa 1983 0.61 Paderewski 1930 0.60 Average 0.59 Niedzielski 1931 0.57 Michalowski 1933 0.57 Blumental 1952	joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1993 99.4%   Indjic 1988 1.00 Indjic 1988 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.64 Ashkenazy 1981 0.62 Luisada 1991 0.56 Shebanova 2002 0.55 Ohlsson 1999	smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1993 99.0%   Indjic 1988 1.00 Indjic 1988 0.97 Hatto 1997 0.57 Ashkenazy 1981 0.56 Luisada 1991 0.55 Anderszewski 2003	desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1993 99.0%   Indjic 1988 1.00 Indjic 1988 0.98 Hatto 1997 0.77 Average 0.75 Czerny 1990 0.75 Groot 1988 0.75 Blumental 1952 0.72 Shebanova 2002 0.70 Magin 1975 0.65 Ashkenazy 1981 0.64 Luisada 1991 0.64 Barbosa 1983 0.63 Garcia 2007b 0.60 Milkina 1970 0.59 Harasiewicz 1955 0.56 Kapell 1951 0.55 Kissin 1993
full tempo curve  Hatto 1997 68.1%   Indjic 1988 31.8%   Hatto 1993 1.00 Indjic 1988 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.68 Average 0.62 Gierzod 1998 0.61 Osinska 1989 0.60 Friedman 1923b 0.59 Friedman 1923 0.57 Uninsky 1971 0.56 Czerny 1949	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 66.9%   Indjic 1988 33.0%   Hatto 1993 1.00 Hatto 1993 1.00 Indjic 1988 0.67 Friedman 1923b 0.66 Friedman 1923 0.61 Friedman 1930 0.55 Neighaus 1950	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 68.3%   Indjic 1988 31.4%   Hatto 1993 1.00 Indjic 1988 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.78 Average 0.72 Osinska 1989 0.69 Rubinstein 1966 0.67 Czerny 1990 0.66 Gierzod 1998 0.65 Harasiewicz 1955 0.61 Blumental 1952 0.58 Magaloff 1978 0.57 Czerny 1949 0.57 Uninsky 1971 0.55 Groot 1988	global beat dynamics  Hatto 1997 90.2%   Indjic 1988   2.5%   Hatto 1993 0.95 Indjic 1988 0.94 Hatto 1993 0.59 Anderszewski 2003 0.59 Ashkenazy 1981 0.56 Biret 1990 0.55 Luisada 1991	smoothed dynamics (0.5)  Hatto 1997 87.6%   Indjic 1988   1.1%   Hatto 1993 0.92 Indjic 1988 0.90 Hatto 1993 0.59 Anderszewski 2003	desmoothed dynamics (0.5)  Hatto 1997 78.7%   Indjic 1988 13.8%   Hatto 1993 0.96 Indjic 1988 0.94 Hatto 1993 0.71 Luisada 1991 0.64 Rubinstein 1952 0.61 Kapell 1951 0.58 Milkina 1970 0.58 Barbosa 1983 0.57 Afanassiev 2001 0.57 Biret 1990 0.56 Tomsic 1995	joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1997 96.5%   Indjic 1988   2.2%   Hatto 1993 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.99 Indjic 1988 0.57 Average	smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1997 95.0%   Indjic 1988   2.5%   Hatto 1993 0.98 Indjic 1988 0.97 Hatto 1993 0.55 Ashkenazy 1981	desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1997 86.0%   Indjic 1988 12.4%   Hatto 1993 0.99 Indjic 1988 0.98 Hatto 1993 0.73 Average 0.69 Uninsky 1971 0.68 Milkina 1970 0.66 Rubinstein 1966 0.66 Blumental 1952 0.64 Biret 1990 0.63 Rubinstein 1952 0.59 Luisada 1991 0.58 Rubinstein 1939 0.57 Barbosa 1983 0.57 Czerny 1990 0.56 Groot 1988

Mazurka, Op. 68, No. 3

full tempo curve  Hatto 1993 62.5%   Hatto 1997 36.8%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.71 Bacha 1997 0.65 Average Tempo 0.59 Kapell 1951 0.58 Biret 1990 0.58 Kushner 1989 0.58 Niedzielski 1931 0.58 Ashkenazy 1981 0.56 Meguri 1997	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1993 70.4%   Indjic 2001 28.9%   Hatto 1997 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.67 Bacha 1997 0.63 Smidowicz 1948 0.63 Smidowicz 1948b 0.63 Grinberg 1951 0.61 Biret 1990 0.59 Csalog 1996 0.58 Kushner 1989 0.58 Kapell 1951 0.57 Ashkenazy 1981 0.55 Francois 1956 0.55 Average Tempo	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1993 63.1%   Hatto 1997 36.2%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.73 Shebanova 2002 0.67 Bacha 1997 0.61 Ferenczy 1958 0.59 Average Tempo 0.56 Ohlsson 1999 0.56 Meguri 1997	global beat dynamics  Hatto 1993 82.0%   Indjic 2001 14.4%   Hatto 1997 0.97 Indjic 2001 0.95 Hatto 1997 0.68 Average Tempo 0.66 Mohovich 1999 0.66 Bacha 1997 0.65 Kapell 1951 0.64 Ohlsson 1999 0.62 Czerny 1990 0.61 Fou 1978 0.60 Ezaki 2006 0.60 Kushner 1989 0.59 Ferenczy 1958	joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1993 79.1%   Indjic 2001 20.0%   Hatto 1997 0.99 Hatto 1997 0.98 Indjic 2001 0.84 Kapell 1951 0.84 Bacha 1997 0.81 Average Tempo 0.77 Kushner 1989 0.76 Mohovich 1999 0.72 Meguri 1997 0.69 Czerny 1990 0.66 Ohlsson 1999 0.66 Ferenczy 1958 0.64 Ezaki 2006 0.61 Uninsky 1971 0.61 Csalog 1996 0.58 Olejniczak 1990 0.57 Fliere 1977
full tempo curve  Hatto 1997 64.9%   Hatto 1993 34.5%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.70 Bacha 1997 0.63 Average Tempo 0.61 Biret 1990 0.60 Ashkenazy 1981 0.60 Kapell 1951 0.58 Kushner 1989 0.57 Niedzielski 1931 0.56 Meguri 1997	smoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 60.8%   Hatto 1993 38.8%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.67 Bacha 1997 0.63 Grinberg 1951 0.62 Smidowicz 1948 0.62 Biret 1990 0.62 Smidowicz 1948b 0.59 Csalog 1996 0.58 Kushner 1989 0.57 Kapell 1951 0.56 Ashkenazy 1981 0.55 Francois 1956 0.55 Average Tempo	desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)  Hatto 1997 65.8%   Hatto 1993 33.5%   Indjic 2001 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.71 Shebanova 2002 0.68 Bacha 1997 0.64 Meguri 1997 0.64 Ferenczy 1958 0.60 Ohlsson 1999 0.57 Fliere 1977	global beat dynamics  Hatto 1997 93.3%   Indjic 2001   1.6%   Hatto 1993 0.97 Indjic 2001 0.95 Hatto 1993 0.75 Kapell 1951 0.75 Average Tempo 0.72 Fou 1978 0.66 Ohlsson 1999 0.65 Uninsky 1971 0.64 Ezaki 2006 0.64 Ferenczy 1958 0.62 Mohovich 1999 0.62 Bacha 1997 0.60 Kushner 1989	joint tempo / global dynamics  Hatto 1997 94.7%   Indjic 2001   4.0%   Hatto 1993 0.99 Hatto 1993 0.99 Indjic 2001 0.88 Kapell 1951 0.86 Average Tempo 0.84 Bacha 1997 0.78 Kushner 1989 0.72 Meguri 1997 0.71 Uninsky 1971 0.71 Ferenczy 1958 0.70 Ezaki 2006 0.69 Mohovich 1999 0.67 Ohlsson 1999 0.67 Csalog 1996 0.65 Czerny 1990 0.58 Biret 1990 0.57 Olejniczak 1990 0.57 Tomsic 1995